How To Select Jewellery That Aligns With Your Personality Traits



Jump To

Jewellery is not just a fashion statement; it’s also an extension of your personality. It reflects who you are and how you want to present yourself to the world. 

Whilst there have been, in the past, as many as 16 different personality types posited, the Myers-Briggs test has now largely been debunked as totally meaningless.

Instead, many contemporary psychologists now believe that there are five main personality traits or ‘dimensions’ – Conscientiousness, Extroversion, Openness, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism, with each person having a delicate balance of each, one often more emphasised than the others.

While of course it’s a little reductionist to put people in a personality box (us humans are all very different and complex beings after all), exploring personality traits can be both insightful and fun. With that in mind, today we’ve teamed up with the good guys at Poco Loco Store to offer some tips on choosing jewellery pieces that align with each trait. Let’s dive in…


Conscientious folk are organised, responsible, and detail-oriented. They value punctuality, discipline, and hard work. When selecting jewellery, conscientious people should opt for timeless, classic designs that exude elegance and sophistication.

Minimalist & Timeless Pieces: Someone who defines as conscientious may well appreciate simplicity and orderliness. Therefore, minimalist and timeless jewellery pieces such as delicate gold or silver chains, classic stud earrings, and thin bangle bracelets would be ideal choices. These pieces are versatile, easy to maintain, and can be worn with a whole host of outfits and levels of formality, making them perfect for someone who values organisation and practicality. 

Commitment-Driven Jewellery: Conscientious people take their commitments seriously and often have a strong sense of responsibility towards others. Commitment-driven, personalised jewellery, such as engraved pendants or initial rings, can serve as a meaningful reminder of their dedication to loved ones or important goals. This thoughtful touch will resonate with their responsible nature and make the piece even more special.

Functional & Practical Accessories: Self-regulation and impulse control is a defining characteristic of conscientiousness, and those with the trait may appreciate functional and practical jewellery items. For example, a stylish watch or a sleek fitness tracker bracelet can help them stay organised and on track with their daily routines while still looking fashionable.

Ethical & Sustainable Jewellery: Conscientious people are likely to be concerned about the impact of their choices on the environment. Ethical and sustainable jewellery options, such as pieces made from recycled materials or sourced from fair-trade suppliers, will appeal to their sense of responsibility and awareness.

Goal-Oriented Charms: To celebrate their achievements and long-term goals, those with a conscientious side might enjoy wearing goal-oriented imagery on a charm bracelet or necklace. These could include symbols representing milestones in their personal or professional lives, such as a graduation cap, a house, or a promotion-related emblem, or simple but subtle signs of wealth or having ‘made it’. This type of jewellery serves as a constant reminder of their accomplishments and motivates them to continue striving for success.


Extroverted personalities are outgoing, energetic, and sociable. They enjoy being the centre of attention and thrive in social situations. For extroverts, bold and eye-catching jewellery pieces that make a statement are the perfect choice.

Bold Statement Pieces: Extroverts are known for their confidence and love for attention, so why not consider something that reflects your larger-than-life persona? A stunning bib necklace or a chunky bracelet would do just the trick. These eye-catching accessories are sure to turn heads and make an extroverted person feel like the star they truly are.

Colour: Another essential factor to consider when choosing jewellery for an extrovert is colour. Bright and vibrant hues are perfect for someone who loves to stand out in a crowd. Think along the lines of colourful gemstone rings, multi-colored beaded necklaces, or even a pair of dazzling rainbow-hued hoop earrings. These lively pieces will not only add a pop of colour to their wardrobe but also showcase their fun-loving nature.

Layering: Extroverts often enjoy experimenting with different styles and expressing themselves through fashion. A layered necklace set or a stack of assorted bangles would be an excellent choice for someone who loves to mix and match their accessories. This way, they can create a unique look that truly represents their outgoing and adventurous spirit.


Individuals with high levels of openness are creative, imaginative, and curious. They appreciate unconventional ideas and have a strong sense of aesthetics. Always open to embracing new experiences, for these free-spirited souls, unique and artistic jewellery pieces that showcase their individuality are ideal.

Unique Conversation Starters: Open-minded folk often appreciate bold and unique designs that make a statement. Opt for eye-catching pieces such as large pendant necklaces, oversized rings, or chandelier earrings that showcase your creative flair and willingness to stand out from the crowd. For example, a stunning geometric necklace or a pair of sculptural earrings can serve as conversation starters and reflect your imaginative nature.

Artisanal & Handcrafted Jewellery: Those with a high degree of openness tend to value craftsmanship and originality. Handcrafted jewellery made by skilled artisans is an excellent choice, as each piece is one-of-a-kind and reflects the creator’s artistic vision. Look for personalised bracelets for sale made from unusual materials or featuring intricate designs, such as a wire-wrapped gemstone or a hand-painted enamel bracelet.

Vintage & Antique Jewellery: People who value openness often have a keen interest in history and nostalgia. Vintage and retro inspired pieces offer a connection to the past while showcasing timeless elegance and charm. Consider investing in a beautiful Art Deco brooch, an Edwardian-era filigree ring, or a Victorian locket to add a touch of historical allure to your collection. 

Customisable Jewellery: As creative individuals, those with the openness trait coursing through their veins may enjoy the opportunity to express themselves through customisable jewellery. Personalised pieces, such as monogrammed pendants, initial rings, or birthstone bracelets, allow you to showcase your individuality and create a meaningful connection to your accessories. Additionally, consider working with a jeweller to design a custom piece that reflects your unique vision and style.

Birthstone Jewellery: Leading on from the above point, people with the openness personality trait are drawn to wearing birthstone jewellery as it allows them to connect with their inner selves and the world around them. Birthstones are believed to possess unique energies that resonate with an individual’s astrological sign, enhancing their personal qualities and promoting self-discovery. By wearing their birthstone, individuals with openness embrace the healing properties of these gemstones, which it’s believed can help release blockages in their physical, mental, and spiritual well-being.

Zodiac Jewellery: People with the openness personality trait like to wear zodiac jewelry as it allows them to express their individuality and connect with others on a deeper level. Wearing zodiac jewellery resonates with their curious nature, as they explore the cosmic heritage and symbolism behind each piece. This type of jewellery also serves as a conversation starter, enabling open-minded individuals to share their interests and beliefs with others. By wearing zodiac jewellery, those with the openness trait can showcase their unique personality, embrace their astrological identity, and foster meaningful connections with like-minded people.

Talisman Jewellery: People who are open are often drawn to talisman jewellery due to their innate curiosity and desire for new experiences. Wearing talisman jewellery like a dreamcatcher, the yin-yang symbol, or the evil eye, allows them to explore the world of symbolism, spirituality, and personal growth. These individuals appreciate the unique qualities and meanings behind each piece, as they resonate with their imaginative and insightful nature.

Talisman jewellery also serves as a tool for self-expression, allowing open-minded individuals to showcase their creativity and individuality. By wearing talismans, they can harness the power of them to support their personal development and enhance their connection to the world around them.

Ethically Sourced & Sustainable Jewellery: As with Conscientious jewellery wearers, open-minded people often have a strong sense of social responsibility and concern for the environment. Choosing ethically sourced and sustainable jewellery options aligns with these values and allows you to make a positive impact through your purchases. Look for brands that prioritise fair labour practices, use recycled materials, or support environmental initiatives, such as conflict-free diamonds or reclaimed gold.


Agreeable personalities are kind, empathetic, and cooperative. They value harmony and are often drawn to symbols of love, peace, and unity. When choosing jewellery, agreeable individuals should look for pieces that represent their compassionate nature.

Charitable Jewellery: As altruistic individuals, those with an agreeable personality type may appreciate jewellery that supports a cause or charity. Many brands offer pieces where a portion of the proceeds goes towards helping various organisations. This allows the wearer to make a positive impact while also enjoying a beautiful accessory.

Symbolic Jewellery: Agreeable people often have a strong sense of empathy and understanding. Therefore, they may appreciate jewellery that carries symbolic meaning, such as pieces featuring symbols of love, friendship, or unity. For example, a necklace with an intertwined heart and infinity symbol could represent the everlasting bond between two people.

Nature-Inspired Jewellery: Given their compassionate nature, individuals with an agreeable personality type may feel a deep connection to the environment and its inhabitants. As such, nature-inspired jewellery pieces, such as leaf-shaped earrings or animal-themed pendants, can resonate with their love for the natural world.

Delicate Designs: Agreeable individuals tend to avoid drawing too much attention to themselves, preferring to focus on the needs of others. As a result, they may gravitate towards delicate and minimalist jewellery designs that subtly complement their outfits without being overly flashy or ostentatious.


Those whose personalities come with a side order of neuroticism tend to be sensitive, anxious, and prone to experience many of life’s rich tapestry of emotions in a short space of time. Because of this, they often seek stability and reassurance in their lives. For those with high neuroticism, calming and soothing jewellery pieces can help provide a sense of balance and serenity.

Personalised Jewellery: Customised pieces, such as engraved pendants or initial rings, can provide a sense of security and familiarity for individuals with a neurotic personality. These personalised items show thoughtfulness and understanding, which can help alleviate any anxiety they may have about receiving gifts.

Understated Designs: Simple jewellery pieces like delicate chains, thin bangles, or small stud earrings can be comforting for those who are high in neuroticism. These understated designs do not draw too much attention, allowing the wearer to feel at ease in various social situations.

Symbolic Jewellery: Since neurotic individuals often possess emotional depth and empathy, they may appreciate jewellery with symbolic meanings. For example, a necklace featuring a tree of life pendant can represent personal growth and resilience, while a piece with an infinity symbol can signify everlasting love or friendship.

Healing Gemstones: Many people believe that certain gemstones possess healing properties and can help balance emotions. For someone with a neurotic personality, consider jewellery featuring stones like amethyst (for calming), rose quartz (for self-love), or black tourmaline (for protection against negativity).

Comfortable Materials: It is crucial to choose jewellery made from comfortable materials, such as hypoallergenic metals or soft fabrics, for individuals with a neurotic tendency. This consideration ensures that the wearer feels at ease and does not experience any irritation or discomfort.

The Bottom Line

Selecting jewellery that aligns with your personality traits is a fun and insightful way to express yourself. By dialling down into what makes you so unique, you can choose pieces that not only complement your style but also enhance your sense of self. So, next time you’re shopping for jewellery, keep these tips in mind and let your true personality shine!

Or, you could of course wear what makes you feel good…

*This article was written to entertain, rather than make affirmative claims about personality types and traits. The science on those traits hasn’t yet reached a consensus.*

Latest From Us

Like That? You'll Love This...

Everybody's clicking on

Just Published...

All Our latest content...